The internet has transformed into a double-edged sword, plagued by issues such as addictive algorithms, data exploitation, and rampant misinformation. In response to these challenges, three notable thinkers—each with a unique perspective on the digital landscape—are stepping forward with bold proposals aimed at revitalizing the web. Among them is the pioneering advocate for “net neutrality,” a former executive from Meta, and the original architect of the internet itself. While their insights are compelling, the question arises: are they truly the right individuals to spearhead this much-needed reform? Each figure presents a firm belief in their vision, yet the complexity of the internet's problems demands a multifaceted approach. As we navigate this digital era, the dialogue around fixing the internet is more crucial than ever, igniting discussions about responsibility, ethics, and the future of online interaction. Embracing innovative ideas could be the key to reclaiming a safer, more equitable internet for all users.