In today's digital landscape, the internet often feels like a double-edged sword, rife with addictive algorithms, data exploitation, and rampant misinformation. Three prominent figures are stepping up to address these pressing issues: the champion of “net neutrality,” a former executive from Meta, and the very inventor of the web. Each has put forth innovative strategies aimed at reforming the online experience to make it safer and more equitable for users. However, their proposed solutions raise an important question—are they truly the right minds to lead this digital overhaul? While they express strong beliefs in their approaches, the challenges of reshaping such a vast and complex ecosystem cannot be underestimated. As we navigate this digital crisis, the need for effective reform has never been clearer. The future of the internet hangs in the balance, and the call for change is louder than ever. Will these visionaries succeed in their quest to repair the internet, or will we continue to grapple with its darker side?